Friday, September 24, 2010

Communication in Engineering

Communication in engineering is crucial between team members and other scholars in the sense that it will allow for greater accomplishments and a merging of ideas.

Considering written communication alone, engineers can made great use of both free writing and directed writing, using them as a tool to improve and expand their projects. For example, free writing often allows for more thought progression as the writer is not as concerned with how his ideas are being presented but more so what the ideas actually are- the reflection on which often produces new ideas or a clearer understanding of existing ones. These freely written forms can also be read by other team members or scholars, who can add insight and possibly further the project even more.

Directed writing, on the other hand, focuses more on the presentation once the idea is solidified and perfected. Writing in this manner is used as a practical way of communication, written in a format that is common and easily followed. In engineering this would often mean writing in a very structured manner and language that eliminates any ambiguities as to the idea and how it works.

It seems to me that free writing fosters thought a great deal more since the writer is not forced into a format and is allowed to focus on the actual subject of the paper and the point that he or she is conveying.

This idea can be transfered to verbal communication as well. It is the same concept as talking freely (bouncing ideas off of teammates, etc) vs giving an oral presentation on the topic. When talking freely with teammates or scholars in the area, the engineer is more open-minded and thoughtful about the topic rather than when he or she is speaking in a more tense, presentation atmosphere.

In essence, communication of both types are needed to make a project understood and widespread but it seems that free-writing or freely talking is present in the developing stages while directed writing/verbal presentations are used in the final stages of the project, once everything is clear and finalized.

4 comments:

  1. Your descripitions of what Free writing and Directed writing are were very accurate and I also liked how you described the importance of Directed writing and Free writing within the workplace of an engineer and workplace of any other proffesion.

    How have you personally incorporated free writing and directed writing into your own classes or clubs here at college? What has your group in Eng 198 done communication wise in order to improve the steam car? And what have you personally done to communicate to a proffesor effectively?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have always thought that writing is not very important for engineers, but I am finding out that this is not true. Can you give some examples of how writing is important in engineering? I don't understand why you can't just write some bullet points, rather than produce a paragraph. Isn't that easier to understand?

    I see that you have outlined the difference between free writing and direct writing. Have you found times when both of these types of writing were important for you? I don't think that I would have the energy to write something out.

    I agree with you on the purpose of communication. It helps people understand what is entailed in a project and what needs to be accomplished. Also good communication allows people to all be on the same page. All in all you have a good understanding for communication and its purposes.
    -Siddharth

    ReplyDelete
  3. First off, it is nice that you quickly summarized what free and directed writing is and their respective benefits. Directed and free writing definitely both have their places.

    As much as writing can help the creative and technical processes, I agree with Siddharth that verbal communication also has its place. Talking with other parts of your team can sometimes be just as effective as putting the ideas down on paper. Sometimes even more so, as there is instant feedback from your listener.

    Anyways, I think we can all agree that a whiteboard is the best thing ever.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I've never thought about how free-writing usually takes place at the beginning of the project while formal writing takes place at the end. I think it has a lot to do with audience and purpose. In the free-writing you are usually talking to someone in your team about a problem or an idea that you had. The formal writing usually is directed towards those outside of your group and has to look professional and as good as possible to impress those that are reading it and make them think that your idea is a good one and that they should invest their time/money/reputation on this project. I like free-writing better because I feel like it uses more colloquial word choice and is less technical and easier to understand.

    ReplyDelete