Friday, October 8, 2010

Toulmin Model

Last year, I was working on a research paper about Reuleaux triangles. They are triangles of constant width and thus, despite having corners, they can roll smoothly. The interesting problem I came upon, however, was how to make a bicycle with Reuleaux triangle wheels to roll smoothly. The shapes work perfectly as rollers but using them as wheels is more complicated as the center of the triangle does not stay the same. As a corner reaches the ground the center rises while when a side/curve is on the ground, the center is lower. It is found that the center actually follows an elliptical curve as the triangle rolls.

After working on this for some time, I came up with the claim that a bicycle with reuleaux triangle wheels can roll smoothly if the wheels are constructed using a two spring system, allowing the frame of the bike to be attached to a fixed point rather than the changing center of the triangle.

The qualifiers or conditions for this claim are that the claim stands for when the bike is already set in motion. Also the springs must be kept tense at all times and the outside ends of the springs must be attached to a material that can slide against the inside of the wheel with minimal friction.

The grounds for this claim are that the triangles have constant width and therefore roll smoothly. Also, springs can be used because they can be held tense at different lengths.

The warrant is that since the triangles can roll smoothly on their own, it is possible for them to roll smoothly in a system. The center of the triangles follow an elliptical curve when rolling, so the springs will be able to account for the changing length between the axle and the elliptical curve carved into the wheel.

The backing is that someone has already constructed a bicycle with reuleaux polygon wheels that rolls smoothly. Guan Baihua has made a model in 2008 and although his was designed differently it also relied on the idea that the bike frame is not attached directly to the center of the wheel. Also, springs are used to adjust for changing lengths in many apparatuses.

4 comments:

  1. I personally have never heard of reuleaux triangles in my life and I found your blog to be extremly interesting.

    Your use of the Toulmin model was extremly well done. Your claim was clear and your qualifier, grounds, warrant and backing were also very easy to comprehend. I would personally not change anything that you have done to your Toulmin model. Your description of what you were trying to portray to the reader was also very well done and in being well done you effectivly got your point across to your audience. So I believe this Toulmin model was very well written.

    Only question I have for you is have you ever made a mini prototype of this to see if it would actually work the way you believe it would?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I haven't heard of reuleaux triangles either. It's a really hard thing for me to visualize- a smooth triangle that still has corners. I think I'd need to see one to get it. Your toulmin model is one of the more complex ones that I've seen. It seems like you did a good job of explaining why your solution would work and you had good backing (especially since its already been done before) to support it. My one question is how did you come up with an idea to make a bicycle out of triangles. I would never have been able to think of that!

    ReplyDelete
  3. First of all I just wanted to say that your project on using triangular system as a wheel is really neat. The idea of using springs to compress and adjust the center of the triangle is also pretty cool. I am not really familiar with this problem, but your application of the toulmin model seems to work well and you have all the different parts. The only thing I would recommend is that you have a list of all the different parts of the toulmin model. I am curious about the problem you have. Have you found a solution that would work in real life and have you tested it because if you have I definitely would like to see what it looks like. It seems like someone has already created this kind of bicycle, have you ever tried to use it. anyways this idea is pretty interesting and thanks for sharing it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi,

    I was not expecting to run into Reuleaux triangles while reading these blogs. Probably because I had never heard of them before. They are really cool to think about and I can see how you would write a research paper on them.

    As for your Toulmin Model, it was very well organized and well written enough so I could follow along without knowing what Reuleaux triangles were before. If you were to present your idea again in the form of a Toulmin Model, I would definitely use pictures, though. It would save you explaining work and let the reader understand the concept quicker.

    Anyways, good job and cool idea!

    ReplyDelete